Milwaukee Astronomical Society

 

Stargazing

Star Hopping

 

Introduction

Big Dipper pointer stars to the North StarWhat is star hopping? It is a technique that amateur astronomers use to find celestial objects in the sky. And that technique at its core is simple and straightforward: it's going from a known part of the sky to an unknown part of the sky. We're hoping this sounds familiar since this is what we've done throughout the Stargazing pages.

As an example, if you can find the Big Dipper in the sky, you can use the two pointer stars to find a single star: the North Star.

Though that does sound simple (and hopefully it is), finding a celestial object that can only be seen in a telescope (or binoculars or a finder scope) will be more challenging. This is where the technique of star hopping is so valuable.

 

Star Hopping With Binoculars

The following star hopping examples show a typical binocular field of view:  8X giving a 7.5° field. Your binoculars may differ. Also, these are just recommended star hops to these objects. There is not a necessarily right way. The right way is the one that works for you!



Andromeda Galaxy The constellation Andromeda is the figure formed by two curved lines of stars that radiate out away from the Great Square, coming off the upper left corner. Andromeda's head is the star at the top left corner of the Square. Going away from the Square, there's a pair of stars at her shoulders, a pair at her hips and a pair for her feet. The second pair of stars, her "hips", points us to the galaxy - follow the line between those stars going up and you'll hit two more stars which just bracket the galaxy nicely for you. It's up and a little to the left of dead center between those two stars, and is very obvious in a pair of binoculars, almost independent of how dark your sky is.



Coathanger Altair is a very bright star, so it's a good place to begin for finding the Coathanger with your binoculars. The two stars on either side of Altair are called the "Pilot Stars" and if you follow their line going up, drift maybe a little to the left, just after you lose the last Pilot Star out of your field of view you will come upon a fairly bright, close pair of stars that form the feathers of Sagitta the Arrow. Keep going up and a little to the right from the feathers and before they even leave your field of view you will come upon the Coathanger. You will know when you see it.

Double Cluster Binocular Finder

Double Cluster To find the Double Cluster we can start with the constellation Perseus. This hero's helmet forms a distinct, if perhaps not very bright, triangle that is easy to recognize in the binoculars. Move the binoculars up in the direction that the triangle is pointing until a fuzzy patch appears at the right-hand edge of the field of view. Center the fuzzy patch and you'll see actually two fuzzy patches - you've found the Double Cluster.

 

Star Hopping With A Telescope

Before discussing the techniques of star hopping with a telescope, we need to address the why: why star hop when we now have GOTO mounts where you can simply push a button and your telescope will slew to the object and probably be right there in the eyepiece for you to see? It is a good question, and not really a new question because before we readily had this technology there were setting circles which could be used to point a telescope at any specific point in the sky.

Obviously, if your telescope doesn't have GOTO capability or setting circles, a star hopping technique will be necessary. But even if you do, there is another reason: star hopping can be fun.

"You can observe a lot by just watching." - Yogi Berra

Star hopping gives you the opportunity to look at parts of the sky that you might otherwise not. Examples are star clusters, nebulas, and maybe even a comet.

 

With a Telrad / 1X finder

Telrad and other 1X finders have become popular finding tools for one basic reason: simplicity of use. They're intuitive and can be mastered quickly. And you only need a standard naked-eye star chart with the position of your target indicated.

By definition all 1X finders don't magnify. All they do is project either a target or simply a red dot in the sky to indicate exactly (assuming they are properly aligned) in the sky the main telescope is pointing.

Telrad Finder

Telrad Finder.

Telrad Sky Target

Telrad Sky Target

The Telrad was the first really popular 1X finder. In the photo above you see the appearance of the target projected onto the sky. And though the "projection" is really an illusion, it's just as effective. Your head position doesn't need to be precise. When you look at the target in the sky and move your head around, you'll see the target reminds pointed exactly. The three project circles are ½°, 2°, and 4° The brightness of the target is adjustable.

There are a variety of other 1X finders, but most of them can be called a "Red Dot Finder" as they simply project a red dot in the sky. Our examples that follow are using the Telrad target.


M57 finder with a Telrad

M57 Notice how the Telrad indicator is positioned relative to the stars of the constellation Lyra the Lyre, particularly the bottom two stars of the parallelogram, β (beta) Lyrae on the right and γ (gamma) Lyrae on the left. The 2° circle is just outside β and also just outside the two stars to the south of β. This circle is also passing between γ and the smaller star to the right, just outside the smaller star. By positioning the Telrad in this fashion, the center is directly over M57, the Ring Nebula, and hence the Ring will show up in the eyepiece.

M13 finder with a Telrad

M13 Here the Telrad is positioned with the 4° circle a little below the upper right star of the Keystone in Hercules, with the ½° circle just touching the line between the two right-hand stars. With this positioning M13 should be within the ½° circle and will show up in the eyepiece.

M51 finder with a Telrad

M51 For locating M51, start near the tip of the handle on the Big Dipper, and note the triangle of stars just below this star. By touching the upper left star of this triangle with the 4° circle, and just touching the line between the two left-hand stars with the ½° circle, M51 should be positioned within the ½° circle and will show up in the eyepiece.

Disadvantages: It can become very difficult to use a 1X finder when observing in light polluted skies or when moonlight is interfering. This is when using a finder scope especially becomes a real advantage. And another problem is when your target is far from any easily visible stars.

Commercial Telrad Finder Charts

With a Finder Scope

What are the advantages of using a magnifying finder? The primary advantage is exactly that: magnification. This raises the pointing precision and it will allow you to see dimmer stars. But a secondary advantage is the view of the sky you get. The view through almost all finder scopes is that of binoculars. Another great reason to have a good finder scope, one with 8X magnification and a 50mm objective is sometimes the view through the finder can be better than that of the main scope.

 

An Example Star Hop Through a Finder
Star hop to M11

Here we present an example of how to locate M11, aka the Wild Duck Cluster. We start by locating the bright star Altair, the southern most member of the Summer Triangle. In our example we are showing a finder scope with a 6° FOV (field of view). So it shows one way to get to the M11 target. Keep in mind there is no real right or wrong way! Whatever works for you is the best.

Circle TemplateKeep in mind your finder scope may have a different FOV because it depends on both the magnification and the apparent FOV. If you print out the star chart you can plan our star hop with a template like we have shown. But you need to find what size circle you need that will correspond to your finder's FOV.

The easiest way to determine the FOV is to simply get it off the specs of your finder. But if that is not available, you can either approximate it (the circle doesn't need to be exact) by looking at stars in the sky. A good pair of stars to look at are the pointer stars of the big dipper, called that because they point to the North Star. These stars are about 5° apart. Another way to get a fairly precise figure is to find a star close to the celestrial equator and time how long it takes to drift out of the field. The star will drift one degree every 4 minutes. But you can see the problem. A typical finder with a 6° field will take 24 minutes to drift that far!




M27 To get to M27 once again begin at the star Altair in Aquila the Eagle, which you can confirm when you see the two Pilot Stars on either side of this star in the viewfinder. Slide the field of view to the North, and shortly after the last Pilot Star shifts out of the viewfinder you should see the distinctive tail feather stars of Sagitta the Arrow slide into view. You can then move along Sagitta to the East, and once you find the two stars forming the tip of the arrow, again shift to the North until you see a grouping of stars in the shape of the letter "M". M27, the Dumbbell Nebula, is right at the central point of the "M". When you look in the eyepiece you should be able to see the hourglass shape of this nebula.



M51 We will use two triangles of stars to locate M51, a large, fairly bright triangle and a tiny triangle, just bright enough to see in the viewfinder. Mizar and Alcor, the double star, can be a good place to start because its unique and distinctive appearance means you can be sure you are targeting the right spot. Also Alcor, the smaller star, points to the East from Mizar, and you can simply slide your field of view to the South to find the large triangle, just about one field of view away. Once you've centered the larger triangle, the tiny one can be used as a reference to determine where M51 should be. Center your crosshairs on that location and you will find M51 in the eyepiece.

Alkaid, the star at the tip of the handle of the Big Dipper, can also be used as a starting point, in which case you will have one star from the large triangle (and possibly one from the tiny triangle) already in your field of view, similarly to above, center the the large triangle in the viewfinder, locate the tiny triangle, then center the crosshairs on M51 using the tiny triangle as your reference.



M104 To find M104, the Sombrero Galaxy, a good place to start is with the constellation Corvus, a very conspicuous trapezoid of stars in the southern Spring sky. The pair of stars at the upper left corner of this trapezoid are δ (delta) and η (eta). These two stars are good, both for confirming your viewfinder is in the right spot, and also establishing orientation, with η, the smaller star, pointing a little north of east from δ. Move the field of view just a little to the north to find a triangle of stars that forms a convenient arrow head pointing you to the Sombrero. When you place this triangle right at the southwest edge of the viewfinder you are right on M104.

 

The Trouble With Finders

Though a big advantage of the finder scope is pointing precision, that assumes you have adequately aligned your finder. Before you use your finder to star hop, it is always a good idea to check that alignment. Point at an easy object like the moon, a planet, or a bright star.

Additional advantages or difficulties depend on the type finder scope and there are 4 of them.

  1. Straight-thru, image upside down

    Straight-thru upside down image finderOnce upon a time this was the only kind of finder scope you could get. The image is upside down and that is the problem. Yes, you can simply print or view your star chart upside down (after all as the saying goes, there is no such thing as right-side up in space), but moving your scope as you view through it needs to be learned because to move the scope to the right, you move it left.

  2. Right-angle finder scope with an amici roof prism.

    Right angle correct image finder As a right-angle finder, you have generally comfortable viewing positions and the unintuitive movement. But the view through this type of prism is actually a correct right-side up and correct left-right (in other words, not a mirror image).

  3. Right-angle finder scope with a standard prism.

    This type of finder has the advantage of generally comfortable viewing positions. But that comes at a big cost: very unintuitive movement. Also, though the view is technically right-side up, it's a mirror image. We have not included a picture because such a finder looks exactly like one with an amici roof prism and you can probably ignore this type of finder as we believe no one manufactures this type any longer.

  4. Straight-thru erect image finder scope.

    Straight-thru correct image finder This type of finder offers the same advantage as upside-down type, but the right-side up adds intuitive operation. Need to move the telescope right, move it to the right! It still has the disadvantage of possibly some awkward head positions, but with the straight-thru view, rough pointing is relatively easy.

 

The Best of Both

Telrad and Finder scope combination

If you can afford it and want the advantages of a 1X finder and a standard finder, you can mount both of them.

 

In the Crosshairs

Single and Dual Crosshairs

All commercial finders come with an eyepiece with crosshairs. The two most common types are shown here: single and dual crosshairs. When properly aligned, they mark the exact point in the sky the telescope is point. Illuminated Finder However, can you see them? Sadly, in relatively light polluted skies, they can be easy. But when you are more dark skies, they may be very difficult to see. So can also purchase finders with illuminated crosshairs. These are usually easy to spot because there will be a module near the eyepice that has the battery compartment. Illuminated finders almost always have a dimmer/brightening dial so adjust the light to just enough light.



Return to Stargazing Home Page

Questions

Your questions and comments regarding the Stargazing section are welcome. You can e-mail the author, Randy Culp for inquiries, suggestions, new ideas or just to chat.
Updated 09 August 2020